This underground Chicago theater just made ‘Amélie’ better than Broadway

Aurora Penepacker and the cast of Kokandy Productions' "Amélie."
Aurora Penepacker and the cast of Kokandy Productions' "Amélie." Photo by Michael Brosilow.

By Lauren Emily Whalen

Amélie has been synonymous with whimsy ever since the 2001 French film launched Audrey Tautou to icon status. A musical adaptation was inevitable, but even Hamilton star Phillipa Soo (most recently in Jesus Christ Superstar at the Hollywood Bowl opposite Cynthia Erivo) in the title role couldn’t guarantee a Broadway hit in 2017. Perhaps, like its celluloid predecessor, Amélie is best when presented with intimacy (as opposed to Broadway’s Walter Kerr Theatre at 975 seats). Thanks to flawless sound design and a terrific cast led by Aurora Penepacker, Kokandy Productions’ innovative Amélie is très magnifique.

Amélie Poulain (Penepacker) has always lived inside her head, thanks to distant and paranoid parents. Now a server at a Paris café, Amélie—inspired by Princess Diana’s recent death and the discovery of a boy’s box of treasures—leaves her apartment to change the world. But when an encounter with shy photographer Nino (Joe Giovannetti) turns personal, Amélie must decide if putting oneself out there is worth potential heartbreak.

(front, l to r) Todd Aulwurm and Aurora Penepacker with the cast of Kokandy Productions’ "Amélie." Photo by Michael Brosilow.
(front, l to r) Todd Aulwurm and Aurora Penepacker with the cast of Kokandy Productions’ “Amélie.” Photo by Michael Brosilow.

Kokandy puts a unique spin on Amélie with a tight, talented ensemble cast, most of whom play several roles as well as musical instruments. Thanks to Lynsy Folckomer and Mackenzie Hahn’s meticulous sound engineering and T.J. Anderson and Anna Wegener’s music direction, Daniel Messé and Nathan Tysen’s score is crystal clear. Director-choreographer Derek Van Barham’s staging leans into the intimacy of the Chopin Theatre’s downstairs space, placing the audience on three sides of the room, including at front row café tables, absorbing them in the action without smothering. The music isn’t particularly memorable, but with a true star in the lead and a lovely message of kindness, does it matter?

Amélie plays at Chicago’s Chopin Theatre through September 28.

1 minute critic 5-star rating

‘Amélie’ takeaway

Sonia Goldberg, Jon Patrick Penick, Aurora Penepacker, Quinn Rigg and Lucas Burr in Kokandy Productions’ Chicago premiere of Amélie. Photo by Michael Brosilow.
(l-r) Sonia Goldberg, Jon Patrick Penick, Aurora Penepacker, Quinn Rigg and Lucas Burr in Kokandy Productions’ of “Amélie.” Photo by Michael Brosilow.

Van Barham calls Amélie a “charming jewel box of a musical”—an apt description. The director-choreographer’s production is classic Chicago storefront theater: a little scrappy, a lot of intimacy and heart. Like many other cities facing skyrocketing real estate costs, Chicago’s storefront theaters face an uphill battle.

“Simply put, without affordable rental spaces, Chicago’s theatre reputation will diminish, and thousands of artists will lose opportunities to create,” Gwendolyn Whiteside, executive artistic director of American Blues Theater, told American Theater. One solution? The next time you’re in Chicago, see a show and support local theater artists.

Traveling to Chicago? Find the best hotels near the Chopin Theatre

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.