Boy meets boy as ‘The Fantasticks’ finally bows on Broadway

Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy in "The Fantasticks." Photo by Joan Marcus.
Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy in "The Fantasticks." Photo by Joan Marcus.

You’ve probably seen The Fantasticks before, just maybe not like this. The familiar: two young lovers who believe their parents don’t want them to wed. The new: an updated twist on the story, where boy meets boy. 

After decades reigning as Off-Broadway’s longest-running musical, The Fantasticks arrives on Broadway in a newly reimagined production. Director-choreographer Christopher Gattelli’s joyous staging maintains the charm, wit, and warmth of this unimpeachable show, even if the move to a bigger stage at times reminds audiences why it succeeded on more intimate ones. 

In Harvey Schmidt and Tom Jones’s delightful musical, Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and Lewis (Nathan Levy) are neighbors who fall in love, and both actors find warm wackiness in their characters’ hormones and naivety. Their mothers are worldlier but, in Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles’s performances, just as hilarious. 

The moms have concocted a plot: to ensure their sons’ romance, they’ll use reverse psychology and disapprove of their love. They build a wall between them (personified here by a suave Ahmad Simmons) and, as they profess in one number, if you want to get your way with your children, “Never Say No.”

An old show in a new key

Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles in "The Fantasticks."
Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles in “The Fantasticks.” Photo by Joan Marcus.

While stories of gay love are not new to the stage, it still feels landmark for a classic like The Fantasticks, which premiered Off-Broadway in 1960, to receive this modern take. The magic is how little needs changing: the show captures the burning romance of adolescence, which knows no bounds. 

That’s true even when El Gallo gets in the way. With a rich baritone, Zane Phillips plays a bandit who also acts as the narrator, crafting tension between the boys so they find their way back to each other. With his bulging muscles, Phillips could easily portray El Gallo as a menacing presence. To his credit, and to the storybook world of Gattelli’s production, Phillips simply beguiles.

Zane Phillips in "The Fantasticks."
Zane Phillips in “The Fantasticks.” Photo by Joan Marcus.

Bigger muscles, bigger orchestra, bigger set: this is Broadway, after all. Eight musicians now play a score that was once handled by piano and harp, and Jason Sherwood’s winning set adds plenty of polish. Still, if part of the original show’s charm was its scrappiness, this upgrade largely preserves its sense of simplicity and play. You can try to remember old versions, or you can just surrender and hum along.

Is ‘The Fantasticks’ worth seeing?

4 star review

Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s musical fable turns out to have always had room for two boys in love, and with Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer scheming on the sidelines, this long-delayed Broadway bow is worth the 66-year wait.

  • Hayes Theater, 240 West 44th Street, New York City
  • Notable performers: Maxim Chlumecky, Nathan Levy, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Ruthie Ann Miles, Zane Phillips, Ahmad Simmons
  • Running time: Approximately two hours and five minutes, including one intermission
  • Performances through February 7, 2027

Have another minute?

Share this: