Blue Man Group crams its greatest hits into an overstuffed Broadway stocking

Blue Man Group 'A New Holiday Surprise'
Blue Man Group 'A New Holiday Surprise'

Fa la la la la la la la what?

In the oddest of worlds and even in the most secular sense, Blue Man Group doesn’t exactly scream holidays. But the bald, blue, and silent trio has gone full yuletide anyway for its first-ever holiday production, which doubles as its Broadway debut at the Lunt-Fontanne through January 3.

The evening unfolds inside scenic designer Michael Atkins’ multi-level mid-century modern set that nails the odd tone: part suburban dream house, part fever dream. An oversized tube television is the evening’s only narrator. Between comic commercials (including one for a health tonic called “Relaxative”), it hands out helpful holiday instructions.

Deck the halls and duck

Fans of the long-running performance art group will find the signature bits present and accounted for, from the paint-splattered drums and latecomer callouts to the marshmallow-catching routine, toilet paper gun and all. The holiday theme gets shoehorned in with all the grace of a five-pound fruitcake crammed into a stocking. Classic carols (with a “Dreidel, Dreidel, Dreidel” thrown in for good measure) bonk out of the PVC pipe instruments. 

As in all Blue Man Group shows, audience participation is part of the mayhem. Here, one hapless audience member becomes the human stencil for a splatter painting that transforms into an abstract Christmas tree. For those not pulled up on stage, inflatable giant tree ornaments bounce around the house. Deck the halls and duck.

Ultimately, it’s the show that was in residence at the intimate Astor Place Theatre for 33 years, only in a Broadway barn with lots of Christmas décor and carols thrown in—nothing new or surprising for a show billing itself as a “new holiday surprise.” But the rowdy toddlers (the production markets itself for ages 3 and up) in the back of the house were having the time of their lives, so who am I to argue with the wisdom of tiny tots with their eyes all aglow?

Is Blue Man Group ‘A New Holiday Surprise’ worth seeing?

3 star review

If you’ve ever spent an evening with Blue Man Group, this is a regift in shinier paper, but anyone looking for low-hanging mistletoe or with a tiny tot in tow will find it a merry, marshmallow-pelted good time.

  • Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, 205 West 46th Street, New York, NY 10036
  • Running time: 90 minutes, no intermission
  • Performances through January 3, 2027

Have another minute?

Stripe post ad
Share this: